Salon Hair Color vs Box Dye: Which One is Best For You?

Posted by Madel Delfin on

If you're thinking about coloring your hair, one of the first questions you may ask yourself is whether to use salon hair color or box dye. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and choosing the right one for you depends on your hair type, budget, and personal preferences.

In this article, we'll explore the differences between salon hair color and box dye and help you make an informed decision.

Difference between salon hair color and box dye

When it comes to coloring your hair, you have two options: salon hair color or box dye. Both have their own pros and cons, so it's important to understand the differences before making a decision.

Salon Hair Color:

Salon hair color is applied by a professional stylist who has been trained in the art of hair coloring. They have access to a wide range of high-quality hair color products, and they can mix and customize shades to suit your individual needs. 

Additionally, salon colorists are experienced in achieving the desired level of color, tone, and depth, ensuring that the final result looks natural and complements your skin tone.

One of the biggest advantages of salon hair color is the personalized service. Your stylist will take into account your hair type, texture, and previous color treatments to create a custom color formula that will help you achieve your desired look. 

Additionally, salon hair color tends to last longer and fade more gracefully than box dye, which can help save you money in the long run.

Box Dye:

Box dye, on the other hand, is a DIY hair color option that you can purchase at most drugstores or online. It typically comes in a pre-mixed formula that is designed to be a one-size-fits-all solution. Box dye is generally more affordable than salon hair color, and it can be convenient if you're short on time and can't make it to the salon.

However, there are some downsides to using box dye. Since it's a one-size-fits-all solution, it may not be suitable for all hair types and textures. Additionally, box dye can be more damaging to your hair than salon color, as it often contains harsh chemicals like ammonia and peroxide. Finally, box dye can be difficult to apply correctly, and mistakes can lead to uneven color or even hair damage.

Moreover, ammonia, a substance that can harm strands and make them dry and brittle, is another ingredient found in a lot of box dye recipes. In order to prevent hair from being harmed during the coloring process, professional hair color formulas frequently don't contain ammonia. Even if your professional colorist uses an ammonia-based product, they are trained to help limit any harm.

The main difference between salon hair color and box dye is the level of customization and expertise involved. While salon hair color can be more expensive, it offers personalized service and a longer-lasting result.

Box dye, on the other hand, can be more affordable and convenient, but it comes with the risk of damage and may not achieve the desired result. Ultimately, the choice between salon hair color and box dye depends on your individual needs and preferences.

salon hair color vs box- dye hair color

Factors to consider when choosing between salon hair color and box dye

When it comes to coloring your hair, there are two options to choose from salon hair color or box dye. Both options have their own advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to consider a few key factors when deciding which one to choose.

  • Level of Expertise
    •

    The level of expertise is an important factor to consider when deciding between salon hair color and box dye. If you're not confident in your ability to achieve the desired result or want a more precise and controlled application, it's best to visit a salon where a professional stylist can provide expert advice and apply the color accurately and evenly. 

    However, if you're experienced with coloring your hair and feel comfortable with the application process, box dye can be a more convenient and affordable option.

  • Customization
    •

    Customization is an important factor to consider when choosing between salon hair color and box dye. If you want a personalized color that is tailored to your individual needs and preferences, salon hair color is the better option.

    A professional stylist can assess your hair type and condition, recommend the best color and application method, and create a customized color that enhances your natural features and makes you look and feel your best.

  • Quality of color
    •

    The quality of the color is an important factor to consider when deciding between salon hair color and box dye. Salon hair color typically offers a higher-quality and longer-lasting color that blends well with your natural hair color, while box dye may result in a less vibrant and shorter-lasting color that can be more prone to fading and damage.

  • Cost
    •

    The cost is also an important factor to consider. Box dyes are generally less expensive than salon hair colors, but the quality of the results can vary. A professional stylist at a salon will typically charge more, but the results are often more consistent and longer-lasting.

  • Convenience
    •

    Convenience is an important factor to consider when choosing between salon hair color and box dye. While box dye may be convenient in some ways, it can also be messy and time-consuming. Salon hair color, on the other hand, may be more convenient in terms of customization, professional handling, and long-lasting results. 

    Ultimately, it's important to weigh the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that best fits your individual needs and preferences.

  • Risk of damage to hair
    •

    The risk of damage to your hair is an important factor to consider when choosing between salon hair color and box dye. Both options have the potential to cause damage to your hair, but the degree of damage can vary depending on the method of application and the quality of the products used.

    Box dyes often contain high levels of ammonia and other harsh chemicals that can strip the hair of its natural oils and cause dryness and breakage. These dyes can also cause uneven color or damage if applied incorrectly or left on for too long.

    On the other hand, professional salon hair color is typically applied by trained stylists who use high-quality products and are skilled in minimizing the risk of damage to the hair. Salons also offer a wider range of coloring options, including more natural-looking shades and highlights, which can be difficult to achieve with box dyes.

  • Color options
    •

    When it comes to color options, a salon may be a better choice if you're looking for a wider range of colors, customization, accurate color results, specialty techniques, or damage prevention.

    However, if you're looking for a more basic color option and are comfortable applying color at home, a box dye may be a suitable option. Ultimately, it's important to consider your individual needs and preferences when choosing between salon hair color and box dye.

  • Longevity of color
    •

    When it comes to the longevity of the color, salon hair color may be a better option if you want a more long-lasting and vibrant result. However, it's important to consider other factors, such as your hair type and condition, desired result, application method, and cost, before making a decision on whether to choose salon hair color or box dye.

    Salon hair color is often more long-lasting than box dye. This is because professional stylists use high-quality products that are designed to provide vibrant, long-lasting color. Additionally, the application process is typically more precise and controlled, which can result in more even color distribution and better color retention.

    Box dye, on the other hand, may not last as long as salon hair color. The quality of the dye can vary depending on the brand, and the application process may not be as precise as it is with salon hair color. This can result in uneven color distribution and faster fading.

  • Results
    •

    The results you want to achieve are essential when choosing between salon hair color and box dye. Although box dye is an affordable and convenient option, it may not provide the precise result you desire.

     If you want a customized, consistent, and healthy-looking result, salon hair color may be the better option for you. It is always a good idea to consult with a professional stylist to determine the best hair coloring approach based on your hair type, condition, and desired results.

    hair coloring

    Pros and Cons of Using Salon Hair Color and Box Dye

    Pros:
    • Personalized Consultation
    • Customized Formulation
    • Corrective Color

    Cons:

    • Salon hair color can be expensive
    • Salon hair color requires regular maintenance to keep the color looking fresh and vibrant.

    Pros:

    • Convenient to use
    • Affordable
    • Offers a wide variety of shades

    Cons:

    • Limited Customization
    • Risk of mistakes
    • Potential damage to hair

    Level of expertise

    Pros:

    • Salon hair color is typically made with high-quality products 
    • Professional stylists have extensive training and experience in hair coloring
    • The level of expertise and attention to detail provided by professional stylists can result in a more natural-looking, long-lasting color.

    Cons:

    • Salon hair color is generally more expensive than box dye, 
    • Scheduling an appointment with a professional stylist can be time-consuming 
    • If you are unsure of the color you want or need, it may require multiple appointments with a professional stylist to achieve the desired result.

    Pros:

    • Box dye is widely available and easily accessible at most drugstores or supermarkets.
    • The cost of box dye is generally less expensive than salon hair color, 
    • Box dye comes with instructions that are easy to follow and typically require little to no previous experience.

    Cons:

    • Box dye requires a significant level of expertise to apply precisely and evenly.
    • The limited range of colors available in box dye can make it difficult to achieve a precise match to your desired color.
    • Box dye can be harsh on hair and scalp and may cause damage or irritation if not applied correctly.

    Cost

    Pros:

    • Professional stylists can customize the color to your individual needs and achieve a more precise result.
    • High-quality products are used, which can help preserve the hair's health and integrity, even after the coloring process.
    • Results are typically longer-lasting, which means you may need fewer touch-ups over time.

    Cons:

    • Salon hair color can be more expensive compared to box dye, especially if you visit a high-end salon or need multiple appointments.
    • Depending on the salon, additional fees may be charged for additional services such as a haircut or blow-dry.

    Pros:

    • Box dye is often less expensive than salon hair color, making it a more budget-friendly option.
    • You can do it yourself at home, which saves you time and money on salon appointments.
    • Box dye is readily available at drugstores, supermarkets, and beauty supply stores, making it easily accessible.

    Cons:

    • The color result can be unpredictable and may not match your desired outcome, which can result in additional costs to correct the color.
    • Box dye can damage the hair, especially if it's already damaged or chemically treated, which can lead to additional costs for hair treatments and products.
    • The color result may not be as long-lasting compared to salon hair color, which means you may need more frequent touch-ups, resulting in additional costs over time.

    Risk of damage to hair

    Pros:

    • Professional stylists use high-quality products that can help reduce the risk of hair damage.
    • They can customize the color and use techniques that help preserve the hair's health and integrity.
    • They can assess the condition of your hair and recommend the best coloring method based on your individual needs.
    • They can provide guidance on how to care for your hair after the coloring process to minimize damage.

    Cons:

    • If the stylist makes a mistake, it can be challenging to correct the color without causing further damage to your hair.

    Pros:

    • Box dye is more affordable and readily available in most drugstores and supermarkets.
    • It is easy to apply at home, and the instructions are simple to follow.
    • The process is quicker than salon hair color.

    Cons:

    • Box dye can be harsh on the hair and scalp, leading to dryness, breakage, and even hair loss in some cases.
    • The results can be unpredictable, and the color may not turn out as expected.
    • Box dye can cause more damage to already damaged or chemically treated hair.

    Color options

    Pros:

    • A wide range of color options are available, including custom shades that can be tailored to your specific preferences.
    • Professional stylists have access to high-quality color products
    • Stylists are trained to mix and apply color in a way that achieves natural-looking, multi-dimensional results.

    Cons:

    • Salon hair color can be more expensive than box dye, particularly for custom color options.
    • The process of coloring hair at a salon can be time-consuming

    Pros:

    • Box dye is readily available at most drugstores and can be purchased online
    • Box dye is typically less expensive than salon hair color

    Cons:

    • Box dye typically offers a limited range of color options, and the result can be unpredictable.
    • The one-size-fits-all approach of box dye may not be suitable for everyone
    • Box dye can be challenging to apply at home, and mistakes can be difficult to correct.

    Longevity of color

    Pros:

    • Long-lasting results
    • Customized color
    • Maintenance advice

    Cons:

    • Higher cost
    • Time-consuming
    • Requires appointments

    Pros:

    • Convenient
    • Affordable
    • Quick application

    Cons:

    • Limited color options
    • Uneven results
    • Shorter lifespan

    Result

    Pros:

    • Customized results
    • Long-lasting results
    • Healthier-looking hair

    Cons:

    • Expensive
    • Time-consuming

    Pros:

    • Cost-effective
    • Easy to use

    Cons:

    • Limited customization
    • Inconsistent results
    • Damage hair

    Convenience

    Pros:

    • Professional stylists will take care of everything
    • A salon appointment typically takes about 2 hours, so it's a quick and easy process
    • With a professional stylist, you can expect consistent, high-quality results that last longer, saving you time and money in the long run.

    Cons:

    • A salon appointment may not be convenient if you have a busy schedule
    • You may have to wait for an appointment if your preferred stylist is booked
    • Visiting a salon for hair color can be more expensive than using box dye at home.

    Pros:

    • Box dye is readily available at most drugstores and supermarkets
    • You can use box dye on your own schedule
    • Box dye is typically less expensive than salon hair color

    Cons:

    • Applying box dye can be messy and time-consuming
    • Box dye may not provide consistent results
    • If you make a mistake while using box dye, it can be challenging to correct or repair the color without professional help.

     

    Ammonia-free and PPD-free professional or salon hair color options for you

  • Ammonia free
    •

    L'Oreal Professionnel INOA. This professional hair color line from L'Oréal is ammonia-free and uses an oil delivery system to help protect the hair and scalp during the coloring process. It also offers a wide range of shades to choose from.

    L'Oreal Professionnel INOA Ammonia-Free Color Set

    Source: L'Oréal Professionnel

  • PPD free
    •

    Wella Professionals Koleston Perfect ME+. This hair color line is free of PPD, as well as ammonia and other harsh chemicals. It uses a special dye molecule that helps to minimize the risk of allergic reactions and provides vibrant, long-lasting color.

    Wella Professionals Koleston Perfect PPD-Free Permanent Hair Color

    Source: Scene the Salon

    Ammonia is a common ingredient in hair color that can be quite harsh and can cause irritation and damage to the hair and scalp. On the other hand, PPD, or paraphenylenediamine, is another common ingredient that can cause allergic reactions in some people. 

    So if you're looking for an ammonia-free and PPD-free hair color option, visit the HairMNL Online Shop. With its variety of ammonia-free and PPD-free hair colors, you're sure to find a hair color that will help you look and feel your best!

    When it comes to choosing between salon hair color and box dye, there are pros and cons to both options. The best choice for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences. It's important to consider factors like your hair type, color goals, and budget when making a decision. 

    If you're unsure which option is right for you, consult with a salon professional who can help you make an informed choice based on your unique hair needs. And if you want professional or salon hair color products make sure to check out the HairMNL Online Shop. We offer a variety of hair color products that will surely fit your needs. 

    Whatever you choose, remember to take good care of your hair and enjoy your new look!

    ← Older Post Newer Post →

    Hair Education

    Hair Care for Filipinos Travelling Abroad: Adjusting to Different Climates

    A Buyer's Guide to the Best Detangling Products on the Market